Which pair of contradictory statements is implied in the passage?

• A. Poetry and visual art are similar; poetry and visual art are different.
• B. Only artists can truly appreciate art; art appreciation is what makes us human.
• C. There is but a single standard by which to judge art; there are many ways to appreciate art.
• D. We can appreciate only that which we recognize; appreciating art is all about being open to the new.

Answer: (D)

The correct choice captures two contrasting ideas concerning art appreciation: the notion that appreciation is contingent upon familiarity and the belief that true appreciation involves openness to new experiences. The first part suggests that individuals can only appreciate art if they recognize it, which implies a restriction based on prior knowledge or exposure. In contrast, the second part argues that real appreciation requires a willingness to be open to unfamiliar and novel artistic expressions, indicating that true understanding and enjoyment of art can stem from exploration beyond known boundaries.

This duality reflects a significant theme in discussions about art—how one's background and preconceived notions can both aid and hinder the experience of engaging with various forms of art. Emphasizing this contradiction suggests that the journey of appreciating art is not merely about what is already known, but also about embracing the unfamiliar, thus encouraging a broader perspective on artistic value.